5 Big Email Marketing Mistakes That Are Hurting Your Campaigns

December 10, 2022
Allen Joseph

Email marketing allows businesses to gain valuable insight into their customers and what they want. It provides a quick, scalable way to generate revenue, improve customer retention, and acquire new users.

However, many companies still don't see email as an effective channel or struggle to run successful email marketing campaigns that drive ROI for their business.

Here are five common email marketing mistakes that might be hurting your email marketing campaign:

1. Not personalizing your emails

Using templates and pre-written content in your email campaigns is a common email marketing mistake. While this will help you scale, it fails to create an authentic brand experience or build relationships with customers. People want to feel like they matter when they receive emails, and generic content doesn't provide that.

Personalize your emails where you can: Use the customer's first name, send targeted product recommendations, etc. If you're sending out a series of related campaign emails, be sure to vary the content and format for each email. Don't just change the subject line or the image in the email!

2. Not segmenting your lists

It's tempting to use one list for all of your subscribers, but doing this prevents you from creating targeted campaigns that resonate with specific groups of people. People want to feel like they're getting something valuable when they receive an email, and if you're sending generic content to every one of your subscribers, they'll never feel that way. For example, a welcome email campaign will not be appropriate for your existing subscribers list.

Create separate lists for different customers or people engaged with specific products or campaigns. You can create these lists based on signup dates, purchases, what products they're interested in, etc. Then you can tailor the content within each of those lists to provide a more personalized experience. Using a good email marketing software can make this task convenient for you.

3. Sending triggered email based on time alone

Triggered-based email campaigns can effectively engage users and drive conversions, but you should never send them out as soon as someone signs up (or even worse, as soon as it's been 30 minutes since they signed up!). People need some time to digest the content within an email before they're ready to act on it. To avoid this mistake:

Ensure to keep your sender reputation high. This score, which internet service providers set, weighs your daily email volume alongside your bounce and unsubscribe rates. The more frequently your emails bounce or result in recipients unsubscribing, the lower your sender reputation. Fewer emails sent may correlate with a higher sender reputation. 

Wait at least a week before you send your first triggered campaign after someone subscribes to your list. Then, instead of sending these emails too frequently, try creating scheduled email campaigns that are sent out based on specific days and times for each user. This will help you deliver content that your users want to see at the right time without overwhelming them.

4. Not utilizing mobile devices

Did you know that about 51% of emails are opened through smartphones? So it's essential to make sure your campaigns are mobile-friendly, or you risk driving away potential customers. In addition, with so many mobile users accessing email through a mobile device nowadays, it's essential to have a clear call-to-action and design elements that work well on a smaller screen.

Ensure your email content is fully optimized for mobile viewing by using larger fonts, removing sidebar or header images, etc. You can also preview your email designs on various mobile devices before sending them out to ensure that all links and buttons are appropriately supported across different operating systems.

5. Not testing your email campaigns

You're probably already familiar with the phrase "test, test, and then test again." That's because it's true! It's impossible to know what will resonate with your customers without running a few tests and A/B split tests. These allow you to compare different template designs and measure performance based on how many people click on links, opt into your list, complete a purchase, or whatever your campaign goal is.

Write up multiple marketing emails then create two different versions of each one (and maybe even three!) Send these tests to small segments of your subscribers at first (maybe 5-10%), so you can understand how each one is performing. Then based on these results, you can send the winner to the rest of your list!

Consider these mistakes before sending your next campaign. Remember that an effective email marketing strategy is more than just sending out emails – it requires creativity and a deep understanding of your customers. If you've been focused on getting as many people to sign up, make sure you also take the time to create the best practices to create better engagement by targeting the right people with emails that are more likely to get opened and acted upon.

Loved What You Read? Stay Inspired!

Don’t miss out on exclusive insights, tips, and updates. Sign up now and be the first to explore fresh ideas!

Recent Posts

Talk-Track Time: Why Harvard’s T²R™ Rule Is the Wake-Up Call Your Sales Team Needs

Harvard finds reps spend only 35 % of their day talking to prospects. This blog unpacks the T²R™ Rule, reveals why admin drains performance, and shares six automation-first tactics to reclaim talk time, speed cycles, and hit quota.

Read More
This is NOT a Byte-Sized Blog (But Your Emails Should Be!)

Belkins’ 2024 data shows emails under 125 words lift reply rates to 9 %. This blog explains why brevity wins, shares success stories, and offers a simple framework value hook, one CTA, tight subject line to craft bite-sized emails that break through crowded inboxes.

Read More
From Zero Noise to Peak Performance How MIT’s O‑ZONE™ Cadence and the P.E.A.K. Framework Fuse into a Single Quota‑Crushing Engine

Tired of vanishing into buyers’ digital noise? This playbook shows how merging MIT’s zero-noise O-ZONE™ timing with the PEAK personalization engine turns the same account list into a revenue geyser. Get day-by-day cadence maps, lightweight AI scoring, and team-friendly change tactics that can double meeting volume without new hires. Buckle up your quota is in for a shock.

Read More
P.E.A.K. Prospecting: Personalization-Engagement-AI-Kickoff to Smash Quotas

Struggling to hit quota? Discover how the PEAK Prospecting framework layered personalization, five-channel cadences, and real-time AI scoring can turn the exact same prospect list into 2× revenue. From pinpointing trigger events to a plug-and-play week-one cadence and a lightweight scoring model, this guide breaks down the math that proves why PEAK can be your fastest path to consistent quota domination.

Read More
ICE Framework (Intent – Cue – Engage): Stanford-Backed Subject-Line Hack for 23 % More Opens

Want 23% more opens in your sales emails? This Stanford-backed 3-word hack (ICE: Intent, Cue, Engage) can do it. Copy the formulas, test them, win more replies!

Read More
Call-After-Click (C-A-C): How to Turn Sub-1 % Callbacks Into Live Conversations

Still dialing into the void? Flip the playbook with Call-After-Click—a trigger-powered move that triples live connects. Less guessing, more real convos.

Read More
Copyright © 2025 Amplispot
homecogenvelopegraduation-hatcamera-videobookmarkuserusersphone-handsetscreensmartphonechart-barsdiamondleafhourglass linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram Skip to content